Sunday, September 28, 2014

The Breaking Crucible of the Mind

Busted explanations...

Christianity has long asserted that faith in God necessitates a trust in Him for things that we cannot explain nor manage by our own power or authority.

Fact is we have limited dominion. So, there are many things we don't comprehend or perceive.

I've had many many conversations in the last year concerning things that we don't know. At the end of each of them, I wasn't frustrated for my lack of knowledge, but by the bewildering acts of my companions disregarding their perceptions in favor of an imagined explanation that would make their God and their universe fit perfectly together within their favorite doctrinal statements.

Ultimately and fundamentally, I leave them long before the conclusion, either by the description of God's omni-something or God's exercise of authority/dominion/power.

The template conversation usually goes like this:

Smart person: I think that God is sovereign over all things.
Dumber person (me): I agree.

Smart person: I think that God meant for my great uncle's dog to die in a fire.
Dumber person (me): How so?

Smart person: Because God is sovereign and knows all things. By his creating the universe, he orchestrates the path of all things.
Dumber person (me): Oh.

Dumber person (me): You don't think that God created chance and chaos and uses that to demonstrate the brokenness of the cosmos, showing us that something isn't right? In other words, God absolves himself of evil by allowing his creative agents, corrupted by sin, to simply get what's coming in a world that is broken?
Smart person: Nope. I believe that God orchestrates events and always exercises his authority over the world. Otherwise he isn't God.

Dumber person (me): Why would God's choice of behaving a different way than your expectations make Him no longer God?
Smart person: It's not my perception. If he didn't exercise his power all the time, then his glory is diminished. If his glory is diminished, then he isn't he most powerful being.

Frustrated person (me): ...

------------------------------------end transmission

Crazy Talk

This brings to question a few things in how we process our faith. When did we start making these extreme ultimatums about our faith in God? If [list random doctrine] isn't true, then God fails to be awesome... or fails to be God... or fails to be as awesome as I thought He was.

This is unhealthy talk for a couple of reasons:
1) When did we suddenly become experts on the unknowable?
2) When did we forsake perception as reality?
3) How does our opinion truly factor into the greatness of God?
4) How does anyone place a scale of greatness on their imaginations? "If unicorns aren't orange, then they aren't as cool as purple ostriches."

Instead, we should approach the world from a hypothetical standpoint, as much stating our lack of understanding as the knowledge we purport to have from scripture or elsewhere. Exhibit some humility and perhaps someone can listen to our babbling without stopping within the conversation long before it ends.

All Things True

All true things meet in a single location: reality. It's true.

If I or someone else, cannot concede their philosophy to reality, then we embrace a sort of craziness from which there is no return. 

Example: Many who strongly adhere to the kind of strong feelings about "God willing" this or that tragedy and ultimately using it for his glory usually get to a point where they discuss God's control over human will. This is always a grand discussion because it usually involves the omniscience of God and also the exertion of God's will over the purposes of man. 

To be clear, scripture makes statements like "The king’s heart is a stream of water in the hand of the LORD; he turns it wherever he will."

I'm not saying that God doesn't control/guide people's will at least sometimes. I'm not saying that it's not describing that sort of relationship with God and humans. Humanity is certainly guided by God's shepherding, but it does not require full puppeteer relationship. Perhaps you could say that God is superimposing his will to our subconscious mind or using natural means to direct his agents to steer our paths. However, one thing is very clear by observation, no one does the opposite of his own heart's desire. This final statement is reality. Nobody does the opposite of her nature. 

So, when we talk about 'choosing God' in a group of people who only talk about God 'choosing humans' the natural question becomes about how that humans really don't get say because their will is transformed and thereby unable to be accounted for in this exchange between humans and God. Or more interesting, God knew their choice and through his original creation (from Adam until the present o'clock) He has ordained their existence and so-called choice.  (Justifiably, people who assert that humans do not choose God do so from an opinion that humans are so depraved that their allegiance to a God who is holy would be an 'act' and thereby be an earning of salvation in some way. My opinion is this: it's difficult to tell a man who trades garbage for a loaf of bread that he earned his trade. I also am of the opinion that a man's acceptation of God's Lordship and assent to his need for a savior does not constitute an act of reconciliation with God--Jesus' blood will suffice for those needs. Neither does faith in Christ constitute an act worthy of salvific grace; however, this is the conduit for our reception and this foolishness will continue to confound us forever.)

To be perfectly fair, I love this explanation because it is creative. However, it presupposes a few things about the world and God's knowing and God's creation. 
1) imagines the world was created with perfect knowledge of the events of the future, not just the end
2) the world is moving through a predefined path that asserts a sort of fatalism
3) God exerts his selection upon individuals, not groups of people (see Ephesians chapter one where God ordains the Gentiles too).

Even if #3 is true (which it might be, but I lean towards the group idea), then we are imagining a perspective for God's interaction with the world that we really can only describe. I can't really understand how a being could create something from nothing nor plan eons of meticulous time nor know the hairs on my head. But to assert an idea that from the beginning God's instance of creation defines the trajectory for all living things is way too presumptuous for my blood. Scripture does not make claims this strong about God's future-knowledge. It certainly demonstrates a planning nature for God and also a present-knowledge and an understanding deeper than our minds can grasp. There is the end-knowing, which is strategic, but doesn't imply tactical. I'll leave you to figure out the difference on your own.

Long story short, the simplest way to describe this interchange with God is to say that I choose God because I saw it happen. I was there. Now, in retrospect I see God's agents influencing me. God's community always comes with the people in it--it is His chosen path for disciples to product disciples. Still, this is perception. To forsake perception in favor of this explanation for this imagined world is bordering insanity. Maybe they jointly are true. Can there be paradoxes for how we see God's invitation into the Kingdom of God? God forbid we should say that a paradox would shame God in some way? I mean to say that if an idea IS reality, then how could it diminish the quality of our relationship with God? What is real, is real.